indiegame.fan
Butter Side Down header art

Butter Side Down

Butter Side Down is a bizarro choose-your-own-choice game. Starring Basil Bonser, Adam Spargo, Grey Michael, Beatrice, Jeep Johnson, and Rotten Ruggerio. Answer questions, take calls, play card games, and solve one hell of a mystery.

Steam Page
Release
September 23, 2025
313 days ago
Steam Reviews
Positive28 reviews100.0%

Does this feel indie?

Vote based on whether this game feels indie to you. You can change your vote at any time. Results earn an IGF score after 10 accepted votes.
No votes yet
Vote on More Games
Game contextLatest: IGF Team
ContextThe evidence factors used to assess whether this game belongs on IndieGame.Fan.Status
Notes
Latest Contributor: IGF TeamEdit notes
Updated: Jul 14, 2026Developer scaleThe operating scale of the game's developer.
Updated: Jul 14, 2026Publisher scaleThe operating scale of the game's publisher.
Updated: Jul 14, 2026Publisher statusHow the game's publishing relationship is classified.
Search Google: How is Butter Side Down and Kalle MacDonald and Lachlan MacDonald funded?FundingThe known source of funding behind the game.
Updated: Jul 14, 2026Creative controlWho appears to retain creative control of the game.
Updated: Jul 14, 2026Release statusWhether and how the game has been released.

Media

13 items

About the Game

Butter Side Down is a bizarro choose-your-own-choice game. Starring Basil Bonser, Adam Spargo, Grey Michael, Beatrice, Jeep Johnson, and Rotten Ruggerio. Answer questions, take calls, play card games, and solve one hell of a mystery.

FEATURING

  • An All Star Cast: Basil Bonser, Adam Spargo, Grey Michael, Beatrice, Jeep Johnson, Rotten Ruggerio, and more!

  • Legendary Factions: The F.A.C.T.S. Department, The Money Men, Da Union, and The Company Of Jesters.

  • The BC-3: A fully-featured, period-accurate virtual computer.

  • Question Answering: Your choices will determine the ultimate fate of your coworkers.

  • Phone Calls: Call your coworkers. Receive calls from strangers. It’s fun!

  • Card Games: Play classic card games like Sacrimoni Slap and Brannigan’s Wager. 

  • SNDSCP-305: A soundtrack built dynamically based on your choices.

  • Multiple Endings: There are 45 endings. Or more?

  • One Hell Of A Mystery: Join the hunt for the truth.

  • And More: Extras, secrets, and achievements.